data1701d (He/Him)

“Life forms. You precious little lifeforms. You tiny little lifeforms. Where are you?”

- Lt. Cmdr Data, Star Trek: Generations

  • 9 Posts
  • 545 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 7th, 2024

help-circle
  • This is incredibly cynical advice.

    There’s a hair of truth in here, in the sense that people often don’t know what is best for them outside their area of expertise, and you may need to act decisively to make sure their best interests are served, sometimes regardless of their feelings.

    However, just because you know better than someone doesn’t mean you know better enough to know what’s best for them.

    Deciding whether you know better enough is sometimes a personal judgement, but here I know that OP knows better enough, but not enough to make this decision for the whole family.

    For instance, I remember a time when I decided I knew better and accidentally took down the family Wi-Fi trying to set up a “better” DNS server.


  • Basically, sometimes someone needs to add another function to Excel, so they write a program in a language called Visual Basic that extends Excel.

    Your dad might be using macros and not even realizing it; they’re sometimes embedded in spreadsheets, or his organization may have given him instructions to install them many years ago that he doesn’t remember. He probably expects things to just work, and these very much won’t on anything except Windows since Visual Basic is only on Windows.

    The only way to know is check every Excel setting and spreadsheet, and even then, if he’s doing serious work on the computer, who’s to say work won’t give him a task that requires them in the future?







  • Here’s the nutshell, along with extended info in spoilers:

    Your computer is broken; you may be at risk of losing data, and Linux won’t fix it.

    The speed plus the noise sounds like either CPU fan failure or hard drive failure. CPU fans are cheap to replace; hard drives aren’t right now.

    Thus, if it’s not the CPU fan, it’s probably not worth blowing a bunch of money on an aging computer to replace parts when other things will probably break; also, back up that computer ASAP.

    10+ years is a long time to use a computer, and it’s great that you were resourceful and kept using that thing instead of being wasteful, but you will thank yourself for just getting a new computer.

    If you’re on a constrained budget, you could probably get a computer from five or so years ago so long as it has enough RAM.

    “Good” Microsoft Office compatibility often isn’t enough, especially when it comes to Excel macros.

    Even if your dad doesn’t use macros, maybe he depends on collaborative editing features with a Microsoft account (although this can be done with Office Web).

    Your dad might be so used to Office, he doesn’t even realize what features he uses, and the only to know is to watch him dk his work, which might be annoying.

    Also, if you’re dad’s using this for professional work with a broader organization or company, he probably can’t afford to have anything less than perfect MS Office compatibility.

    I will say, OnlyOffice/EuroOffice actually seems to do a pretty good job with format compatibility (LibreOffice not so much), but my points still stand.

    Don’t turn your family into guinea pigs.

    No matter how well you think you or they are prepared, they’re ultimately getting turned into an experiment here; you don’t want this.

    On one level, you probably don’t want to accidentally hurt or annoy your family by causing data loss or hurting productivity when you’re not around to fix problems.

    On another, you’ll be responsible for anything that goes wrong, and you really don’t want to be in that position no matter how good you are, for the sake of your relationship with your family and own sanity.

    Also, drive partitioning, while not necessarily hard, is easy to mess up; I’m relatively experienced and have still messed up a few times, sometimes to disastrous or at least annoying consequences.

    I love Linux, but people have to want it; you shouldn’t go evangelizing for it, especially if it means pushing it on your family.

    Keep going in your Linux journey, but find somewhere safe to do it.

    I personally learned Linux by tinkering with it in a VM for several years before deciding to daily-drive it. Pretty much anything made since about 2010 should be able to run a Linux VM pretty okay, as long as it has enough RAM and storage.

    Also please wait until you have your own computer to try Linux outside a VM; you could probably find a pretty cheap used laptop that would do the trick.





    1. Alpine is still a Linux distro, just a lighter one. Also, busybox is a set of standard utilities as an alternative to coreutils; I have no idea how it’s particularly relevant here.
    2. The thing is, I’m not using only Docker. I also use native nginx as a reverse proxy, for which I like Debian’s defaults, as well as SyncThing, which are both well-maintained packages in Debian. Also I kind of prefer glibc distros. While glibc kind of sucks, so much stuff I like using prefers or requires it; for instance, last I saw, mDNS/Avahi resolution on BusyBox was kind of a pain in the rear.
    3. Most of what I use Flatpak for isn’t network-facing or opening unverified files anyway; the most important applications I do run the native Debian version. Honestly, truth be told, you are correct that I do often prefer native versions and will run the native Debian package if possible (and considering the current age of stable, a lot of them really aren’t that old; Inkscape is basically still the latest version, for instance, while Firefox is always kept to the latest ESR); at some point, though, I do find a Debian package that is too behind to do what I do (though rare, TBH), and despite some issues with Flatpak, at the end of the day, I need to just get a piece of software installed and get on with my day. In that case, I just do a Benjamin Sisko:

    Benjamin Sisko says “I can live with it”


  • Honestly, in the age of Flatpak and containerization (as well as Debian often being well-supported by upstream projects for script or package-based install), I feel like the age of Debian packages isn’t that annoying anymore; anything important gets security patches, and it’s easier than ever to use 3rd party software without breaking your system. I will add that Debian seems to be much better these days at making sure either a reasonably up-to-date version ships with a release (and can be kept secure during a stable cycle) or not shipping it at all as to allow the user to install it themselves.

    I remember back in just 2021 when it took months after Firefox ESR 78 went EOL for them to update Bullseye to 91; recently, it only took them a few days after 140’s EOL to switch to 153 (and 91-115 and 115-140 happened without much note either), which isn’t perfect, but much better than it was.

    If you need to install it on a new laptop, backports often has you covered. I ran a backports kernel for about a year on Debian Bookworm to get my laptop’s Wi-Fi modem working; I was able to quit using the backports kernel once Trixie came out.