Original question by @StarvingMartist@sh.itjust.works
I’ll start, RuneScape, it used to be about adventure but now it’s about efficiency. Runner up, rust, very active community, but toxic playerbase and people usually abandon when a world isn’t fresh
Overwatch, and the flaw is everything they ruined it with in almost every update since 20172018. I loved how tactical and strategic it was for a shooter, and the only problems it had were the turrets. Everything they have done has been to make it less strategic and more lobotomized and left click focused.