Asking because of Air India 171. Pilots and their unions are objecting to it because of “privacy” reasons. What do you think about it?
Asking because of Air India 171. Pilots and their unions are objecting to it because of “privacy” reasons. What do you think about it?
Agree with your overall point, but in this Air India case a visual definitely would help to see which pilot (if any) flicked those switches to off. The audio is ambiguous.
Wouldn’t the state of the switches be logged on the flight recorder?
Yes, but it might be very important to determine: did the pilot/copilot flick the switch, or did the switch change state without user input?
Is the crew at fault (training issue/operator error) or is the manufacturer at fault (design flaw) or was the ground crew at fault (improper maintenance)?
A camera could help determine that, if it had the right field of view.
Mechanical switches aren’t flipping themselves 4 seconds apart
No, but a short circuit might
it is, mentour pilot released a video about the preliminary report the other day where it’s mentioned that the fuel pumps were set back to active with a 4 second delay between flipping each switch.
this link should be set to the time stamp where he goes over what happened with the switches: https://youtu.be/lVS76zcpZok?t=1102